I have been bringing Noey for Mandarin Playclub classes at Julia Gabriel for the last 3 weeks and today was the last lesson for the term.
I have always been a little worried about Noey learning Chinese, as any Chinese parent with a child who would have to enter the school system here would be. We speak English exclusively at home. Even my parents speak English all the time. We don’t watch much TV, in English or Mandarin. The only Mandarin he hears regularly would be from my aunt (who would be around on the 2 days a week that my Mum looks after Noey) and from my mother-in-law. Unfortunately they both also tend to switch to English a fair bit cos I guess that’s the only way they can get him to understand and respond to them!
We (or at least I) REALLY wanted to have one parent speak to him exclusively in Mandarin and the other exclusively in English, but in the end, neither of us were really comfortable or fluent enough in the language to take on the challenge. Seriously, while I got through Mandarin in school fairly well, my Mandarin these days is really shocking, the victim of neglect and disuse.
So I decided to do what I love to do: Bring Noey for a class.
Especially with Noey just absorbing everything these days, I figured this was the opportunity for me to imprint some Chinese on his consciousness. I toyed with the idea of joining the bilingual class but in the end I thought if I wanted him to get comfortable with the language, I should just go the whole hog and bring him for the Mandarin class.
I think he was rather stunned during the first trial class when the teachers spoke to him in Mandarin to whole time. He kept clinging to me rather alarmedly whenever they tried to approach him. But towards the end of the 2 hours, he became receptive enough to repeat his own name, and say 再见 and 谢谢 when asked. I was encouraged, and since there were only 3 weeks left to the term at that point, I thought there was no harm letting him finish off the 3 weeks and see how he fares.
3 weeks ended today and I must say, he has improved by leaps and bounds. That he can repeat a phrase of 2 to 3 words after the teacher fairly accurately, I am not surprised. Noey is quite the tape recorder after all! But now when you ask him what something is or what colour it is in Mandarin — ie. 这是什么? or 这是什么颜色?– he will answer in Mandarin as long as he knows the answer. So far he can say 花, 大象, 飞机, 苹果, 葡萄, 米饭, 水 and 粉红色. He can also recite the numbers 1 to 5 fairly accurately, with some prompting. In fact one funny thing that has happened is that a few times when I say 是, he has mistaken it for 四 and said 五 in reply. Totally cracks me up.
He also understands much more than he used to and today I realised that he can follow through instructions like 拍拍手 and 点点头 without me gesturing or prompting him. Hurray!
I’ve also taken the opportunity to try to brainwash him into liking Chinese, so now if you ask him if he likes Chinese class, he will say “Yes”, with a smile. Of course when you ask him what he does in Chinese class, his answer is “Play!” which of course really tells you why he likes Chinese class!
I’ve decided to carry on for the next term since the returns thus far seem pretty good! Hey, even my own Chinese is improving as well since I make it a point to speak to him in Mandarin as far as possible during the 2 hour class session. But it’s a huge committment to bring him for class twice a week (that’s the minimum) for 10 weeks, especially since I’m only home 3 afternoons a week. Usually I bring him for classes for interaction and just to get out of the house, but this is the one class where I really want him to learn something. And since he seems to be learning, I guess I’ll be continuing.
Some comments on the class, in case anyone is interested to try it out:
Likes:
– Good class ratio. This is probably due to the fact that Noey is in the weekday 4.30pm class. It isn’t a popular time slot so there are about 8-9 kids with 3 teachers. The teachers therefore do play with/speak to Noey one-on-one quite a bit during each lesson.
– Constant reinforcement. There is a lot of repetition. One key word is covered a week (ie. over 2 lessons) and all the activities centre around the key word so the kids hear it alot. The teacher also scrolls through the entire list of key words on flashcards one-on-one with the kids every lesson and I found that Noey could recognise and repeat the words for the weeks he did not attend because of this.
– Varied outdoor play. There is a schedule that rotates through Water Play (playing with water toys), Sand Play, Swimming (getting wet in wading pools) and Playground activities.
– Teachers. The teachers for Noey’s class are enthusaistic and seem to genuinely love kids, which is a good thing!
Dislikes:
– The fact that they insist that kids sit down and listen quite a bit. Maybe it’s because I have an active son but I think that kids this age should still be allowed to roam a bit, though I do agree that it shouldn’t be disruptive to the class. If he’s not interested to sit down and listen, he just isn’t. Then again I appreciate the fact that they really want the kids to be involved in what’s going on.
– The institution feels a bit cold and too business oriented. Maybe it’s the folks at the front desk that give off that all-too-efficient vibe. That and their strict policies on make-up classes, withdrawals, etc. I understand that the Company is quite a behemoth with centres/schools scattered nationally and internationally so they need some rules, but I contrast this to Playdays which really has that warmth that makes you feel right at home, and flexible policies on make-up classes, and I’m not feeling the love at JG!
Michelle says
The next time someone tries to tell me the reasons behind Bean's slow development in speech is due to the fact that boys start talking later and because we keep talking to him in both languages equally instead of just one, I'll refer them to your blog.<br /><br />Noey is such a genius
corsage says
I recently went to check out JG coz I was in the area, so it is so neat to read this post! I'm totally in the same boat as you on the Mandarin front, made worse because the hubs never formally learnt the language. Noey has such a cute voice by the way (saw a vid on FB)!
Jus says
Hello… came across your blog while browsing… Hmmm, I am worried about my boy's Mandarin too since we hardly speak it at home. Perhaps we might try classes next time. But I do agree with you: Educational institutes that are business-oriented scare me off. And getting kids that age to sit down most of the time seems a tad demanding… Ah well. At least he's enjoying classes and
Daphne says
super impressive!
BeanBean says
Momo :: He's no genius lah. I'm sure Bean understands way more Mandarin than Noey. And the fact that you guys speak to him equally in both languages is really going to benefit him in the long run. I'm sure it is just a matter of time before they are all yanbering away together! (Then maybe we mummies can have a break!)<br /><br />Corsage :: Oh, are you thinking of bringing Little A
sockling says
Glad to know that Noey enjoyed mandarin. It must be quite amusing, hearing him speak the language when he normally doesn't. <br /><br />I have the opposite problem at home – i.e. I worry about Xy picking up English rather than Mandarin. <br /><br />Everyone's been telling me that it will be ok once she gets to school. I am keeping my fingers crossed and in the meantime, we're trying
Daphne (motherinc) says
This is a super timely post since I'm starting to panic a little (also a little early) with Truett turning two very soon and also knowing a grand total of …TWO chinese words. And if 哈哈 doesn't count i'm pretty much screwed!<br /><br />Kidding aside, I've heard really good reviews of JG's mandarin classes. They were kind enough to pass me a CD with some Chinese lullabyes
Chocklitmom says
Aidan goes for the bilingual playclub. Very ex but I like the classes at JG better than Growing Up Gifted. The Chinese teachers at JG are really good, so you're in good hands. Aidan couldn't sit still at first as well but after a number of lessons, he caught on and can now sit through a whole story. So…hang in there!
BeanBean says
sockling :: oh, we have a friend whose daughter is the same — she speaks super fluent mandarin (to the envy of us all!) thanks to her taiwanese grandma who is her regular caregiver. and her mum too. they were concerned about her english too but she picked it up really quickly during N1. so not to belittle your concern, but i think Xy should be alright! english is an easier language to pick up
lazymummy says
I do have to agree that JG front desk staffs are quite stiff.<br /><br />Their teachers on the other hand are really good. <br /><br />Chloe is also suffering for her mandarin cos both hubby & I speaks English all the time. Ironic part is<br />both of us can speak ok Mandarin. It's so tough to switch now cos Chloe will only answer in English.
BeanBean says
lazymummy :: Hi there, thanks for visiting. Everyone tells me the same thing about the teachers, which is the most important thing I guess! Hey, if your Chinese is ok, let least you'll be able to help Chloe with her homework if the need arises in future. I haven't figured out what I'll do yet. Haha.